For many homeowners, the decision to sell their property comes with a significant temptation: handling the sale themselves to avoid paying an agent's commission. The logic seems straightforward—by cutting out the middleman, you keep more of the profit. This path, known as "For Sale By Owner" or FSBO, appeals to the desire to maximize returns on what is often a person's largest asset.
However, a close analysis of recent market data reveals a significant flaw in this logic. The perceived savings on commission are often erased by hidden costs, unforeseen challenges, and—most critically—a substantially lower final sale price. This article uncovers five surprising truths, backed by market data and expert analysis, that every potential FSBO seller should consider before planting that sign in their front yard.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The most significant and counter-intuitive finding from real estate market analysis is that FSBO homes statistically sell for substantially less than those listed with an agent. The primary motivation for going FSBO—to save money—is often undermined by this stark price gap.
According to the National Association of REALTORS® (NAR), the median sale price for an FSBO home last year was $380,000, compared to a median of $435,000 for homes sold with agent assistance. This represents a **$55,000 difference**—a staggering loss that, for most sellers, would be more than five times the cost of a typical agent's commission. Other data reinforces this trend, finding that FSBO homes sold for a median price that was 23% less than agent-assisted sales.
One of the biggest challenges for unrepresented sellers is accurately pricing their home. Homeowners are emotionally invested in their property, and that personal attachment can cloud the objective judgment needed to set a competitive price that reflects true market value.
Data from a Clever Offers survey highlights this struggle: one in four FSBO sellers found setting the right price difficult, and 41% later wished they had priced their home differently. In sharp contrast, 81% of sellers who worked with an agent felt their home was priced correctly from the start. Real estate agent Alex Boylan pinpoints why this happens:
"The reality is you didn’t get your house priced right because you have someone who is emotional about their home pricing it. They give it a value that they feel it’s worth. It’s a lot higher than true market value."
Overpricing can cause a home to sit on the market for an extended period, leading potential buyers to wonder if something is wrong with the property. Underpricing, on the other hand, means leaving a significant amount of money on the table.
A common belief is that FSBO sales are faster because they cut out the agent. While some data shows FSBO homes selling a week faster on average, this statistic comes with a major caveat: it's typically because the seller already knew the buyer. In 2024, this scenario applied to 38% of FSBO sellers, making the "speed" an irrelevant benchmark for those marketing their home to the general public.
For sellers who need to find a buyer, the opposite is often true. A Clever Offers survey found that 65% of agent-assisted sellers received an offer within two months, compared to only 51% of sellers who went it alone. The risk of a prolonged, unsuccessful sale is not just theoretical. Infamously, the owner of ForSaleByOwner.com tried and failed to sell his own condo, which languished on the market for six months before he ultimately hired a professional real estate agent. This reality is reflected in seller sentiment, with 34% of unrepresented sellers stating they believed their home would have sold faster if they had used an agent.
Selling a home involves far more than just accepting the highest offer. It requires navigating complex negotiations over critical items like home inspection results, appraisal contingencies, and closing timelines. An unrepresented seller is often negotiating directly with an experienced buyer's agent whose sole job is to secure the best possible deal for their client.
Survey data reveals that nearly half of those who sold on their own felt intimidated dealing directly with these seasoned professionals. This creates a clear disadvantage. Furthermore, some buyers' agents may be reluctant to engage with FSBO listings, as explained by agent Alex Boylan:
"As a buyer’s agent working with a For Sale By Owner, you work a lot harder, and you make a lot less money. I steer my clients away from For Sale By Owners."
This professional reluctance can limit the pool of potential buyers for an FSBO property, as some agents may simply avoid showing the listing to their clients altogether.
The FSBO process is often far more demanding and stressful than sellers anticipate. More than half of unrepresented sellers reported feeling overwhelmed by the tasks involved, from marketing and staging to legal paperwork and negotiations.
This difficulty is reflected in overall satisfaction rates. While 86% of sellers who used an agent were happy with their choice, that number drops to just 71% for those who did not. The satisfaction gap between agent-assisted (86%) and unrepresented (71%) sellers is a significant 15 percentage points. Ultimately, 36% of non-traditional sellers wish they had used a professional agent, with their top regret being that the process took significantly more work than they had anticipated. This high rate of regret underscores a fundamental truth found in the data: a vast majority of sellers (87%) still view traditional agents as the most trusted path for handling their largest financial asset. And while some represented sellers felt their agent's commission was high, a resounding 82% still concluded that a good agent is worth the cost.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The decision to sell FSBO hinges on a gamble: that the potential savings from a 3-6% commission will outweigh the documented risk of selling for up to 23% less. The data consistently suggests that selling a home "by owner" is a high-risk proposition, often fraught with challenges that lead to a lower sale price, a more stressful process, and a higher probability of regret. Before you decide to go it alone, is the potential saving on commission worth the proven risks to your time, sanity, and final profit?